The title of this blog is something that we, as Christians, are very familiar with. We get that phrase throughout the Bible, but we see that exact phrase when John says “God is Love” in 1 John 4:8. The question I will try to answer in this blog post is what type(s) of love God, Christians and Unsaved are.
You may be asking at this point, “What does he mean by types?” Well, in the Greek culture there are three forms of love. I will give the Greek word and a definition of the word. After I have given the explanation of the word I will then give an interpretation of what the words mean. I am not a scholar and I have not been in school all of my life, so if I say anything that does not agree with the Bible please let me know, so that I can remove this post from my blog. This post is only my thoughts on the subject.
αγαπη – (ag-ah-pay) “love, that is, affection or benevolence” [1]
φιλεω – (fil-eh-o) “to be a friend to (fond of [an individual or an object]), that is, have affection for (denoting personal attachment, as a matter of sentiment or feeling;”[2]
ερως – (er-rose) (this form is not in a dictionary as a verb rather it is the noun of Eros the Greek God, so I will give my own definition) “This type of ‘love’ does not worry about the other person involved, rather they take everything from that person.
αγαπη– Giving 100% of the love no matter the person, no matter the past, present, or future. The “I will love you always”
φιλεω – Give 50% / Take 50% this is the brotherly/friendship love. The “You scratch my back and I’ll scratch yours type”
ερως – Take 100% irregardless of the party involved. Most of the time used sexually, but the sexual has a deeper reasoning than just sexual. This is the “Give me everything you have and I will give you nothing in return. My use of this term in this blog with is used as just this; there will be no sexual connotation used with this word.
With all of this being explained I will now begin the controversy. I will begin with applying each love to the three groups of people. I will begin with the unsaved, move to the saved and finish with God. I will be using the English transliteration of the word (i.e. agape rather than αγαπη) Without further distractions I will begin with my game plan my nine major points.
Sinners Saved God
Are Eros Cannot be Eros Is Eros
Think they are Phileo Are Phileo Cannot be Phileo
Cannot be Agape Should be Agape Is Agape
As stated before I will begin my explanation with sinners. The first form of love I attached to them was the Eros for and I will begin my explanation with that. The reason I believe they are Eros is because they don’t realize who their maker is; they don’t realize that their very life and breath comes from God. Instead, they continue to take from God without giving Him credit for anything. Every human being has been in this boat in their life. Whether a person is a Christian or unsaved they have been in this boat because we are depraved human beings.
In Psalm 51 David says that he was conceived in sin. Of course who could for get the words of Jesus when he said “You people are from your father the devil, and you want to do what your father desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not uphold the truth, because there is no truth in him. Whenever he lies, he speaks according to his own nature, because he is a liar and the father of lies.” Romans 14:23 says that whatever we do outside of faith is sin. With this being said this shows that unsaved people are the Eros form of love.
The second phrase “Sinners think they are the Phileo form of love. People, especially those that believe in a God just not the one of Christianity, think that the things they do, whether good or bad, will gain (or lose) their spot in Heaven. Even for people that don’t believe in a god they believe that if they do something the cosmos will look on their kindness and something good will happen to them. It would be something like karma that they would believe in.
The last phrase about sinners would be that they cannot be Agape. The place the Agape form was coined was in the Bible. It is used about 135 times when the New Testament talks about love. The other form is used about 20 times. Every time the Agape form is used is in reference to Christians and it is because God is dwelling in us that give us the ability to love others with Agape.
The second group I will be writing on is Christians. I began with saying that Christians cannot be the Eros form of love. We, as Christians, cannot be the Eros form of love because God dwells in us. If we, after “getting saved,” demand and take things from people, proves that we weren’t saved to begin with. Jesus says we should “love our enemies and pray for those that persecute us.” We should love everyone because we have been forgiven of so much.
The second phrase was that Christians are Phileo love. We have been forgiven of so much and because of this we now show love to everyone, but because of our sin nature we don’t love correctly. We are grateful to God for everything He has given us, but we still feel in our hearts that “If I Read my Bible everyday. Then God will bless me with wealth” or “If I stay pure until I am married then God will appease me and give me a wife when I ask for one.” God is not a dog that you toss your bone at and he brings it back to you. I will explain more about this when I get to God and Phileo.
The last phrase I used was that Christians should be Agape form of love. I dare say that not one person reading this could say they have the Agape form of love. I am not saying this out of pride because I am far from Agape, but this is what we should all strive to be. We should all strive to love and pray for our enemies. Not because if we do that we earn our salvation or that God will do good things for us, but because God has done so much for us that we can’t help but to love those around us no matter what they’ve done to us.
On the list I gave towards the top I said that God was Eros, but before I explain that I want to explain the other two.
The second phrase I mentioned was that God cannot be Phileo. If God were this way He would be this way for everyone. He would not do this out of love, but out of His equality. Instead, we see that Christians ask for things and He may or may not answer it the way we ask for it. If God has Phileo love then when we would scratch His back; He would scratch ours because he would be compelled to.
The third phrase I used was God is Agape. God loves us no matter what we did, are doing, or will do. He loves us completely and totally with no questions asked. That’s why John said “God is love (Agape).” We see this through the entire life of Jesus up until His death on the cross.
The first phrase that I saved for last was God is Eros. One could ask “Is that not a contradiction from what you said in the previous paragraph about God being Agape?” “Isn’t Eros the opposite of Agape?” To which I would answer “Hold your horses I will answer these and many other questions you may have including ‘Has he lost his mind?’”
To begin with God is Eros because of how He is viewed in the Bible. On multiple occasions we see that we are “servants,” but this isn’t necessarily the case. The word “servant” comes from the Greek word δοῦλος (doulos) which should be translated “slave.” Which means when God says “Well done my good and faithful servant”, He is really saying ‘slave,’ so, we are God’s slaves. If we are the slaves and he is the Master we have nothing. When we come to Christ we are nothing. After we come to Christ we are still nothing. God takes everything we “have” because of His love for Himself.
This is what is so great! God gives us everything He demands from us. Let that sink in. Before we come to Christ we are nothing. After we come to Christ God gives us everything He demands from us even though we are nothing. If God demands everything of our nothing then that makes God look so great because He is providing everything He is demanding. God demands we have faith in Him; He gives us that faith. God demands we love our enemies; He gives us that love to love our enemies. God demands that we have self-control; and He gives us that self control. How amazing is that! That is like the IRS saying you owe $100,000 in back taxes; then turning around and giving you a check for $100,000.
I am not setting any of this in stone because my opinion can change. This is research that I have done and hypotheses that I have come up with.
[1] Strong, James. “αγαπη” Def. 26. The New Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance. 1984. 7.
[2] Strong, James. “φιλεω” Def. 5363. The New Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance. 1984. 75.